Chapter 5 - THE SECOND DRESS

The message contained no words, only the photograph and a location: a storage unit on the south side of Chicago.
Linda wanted to call the police. I wanted to call James. Charlotte insisted we do neither until we knew what we were walking into.
“We can’t just go there,” I told her.
“I know,” she said. “That’s why we should take Aunt Linda and a lawyer.”
She was fourteen, but the night had forced her into a kind of adulthood no child should have to carry. I hated that she was the one thinking clearly while I struggled to breathe.
The next morning, we met attorney Simone Price in her downtown office. She had handled my mother’s estate and was one of the few people who had never treated me as an accessory to James’s success. She examined the photograph, the original shareholder agreement, and the payment records.
“The documents suggest fraud,” she said. “But the hospital bracelet introduces a separate question. We should not touch the storage unit without documenting everything.”
She arranged for a private investigator and a witness. By noon, we were standing outside a metal door in a row of dusty storage units. The manager opened it with a master key and waited while Simone recorded the entry.
Inside were boxes of fabric, old pattern books, and a garment bag covered in yellowing muslin. The second dress was inside.
It looked almost identical to mine, except for a narrow line of blue thread running along the inner hem. A small tag had been sewn into the lining: R.B. / E.B. / 06-12.
Emily Bennett. My mother had used her maiden name for me in her private notes.
The hospital bracelet lay in a clear plastic sleeve. My name was printed on it, but the date was two days after Charlotte’s birth.
“That’s impossible,” I whispered. “I gave birth at Lakeshore Hospital. I remember every minute.”
Simone didn’t touch the bracelet. “It may be a duplicate, a mislabeled record, or evidence of something serious. We need the hospital file.”
A box beneath the dress contained a ledger with dates and initials. Most entries referred to fittings and deliveries. One entry, written in my mother’s hand, read: E.B. — infant record altered; ask Dr. S.
Charlotte read it twice. “Who is Dr. S.?”
I had a terrible guess. Dr. Samuel Shaw had been the obstetrician who delivered Charlotte. He had retired years ago, but his daughter, Rebecca Shaw, now ran a private women’s health clinic.
Simone photographed every page. The investigator found a second envelope taped under the shelf. It contained a receipt for a payment to Northline Strategies and a letter from my mother to someone named Eleanor.
I did what you asked. I kept the second dress. But I cannot keep the truth from Emily forever. If James finds out, he will destroy the only proof.
The letter was dated three months before Mom died.
“Who was Eleanor?” I asked.
Linda’s face had gone still. “A seamstress who worked with your mother for a while. She left town after a family tragedy. Rose never spoke about her again.”
“Was she the mother of the little girl in the recording?”
“I don’t know.”
The investigator returned from the office carrying a printed access log. Someone had entered the unit twice in the previous month. The first visit was registered under Vanessa Clarke. The second used James’s company card.
So Vanessa hadn’t merely worn my dress. She had been looking for this one.
Simone’s phone rang. She listened, then looked at me. “The hospital confirmed that the number on the bracelet is real. They have a sealed neonatal incident report from the week Charlotte was born. It was flagged by an internal review and never fully resolved.”
I gripped the edge of the shelf.
“Was Charlotte harmed?”
“They won’t disclose details without the proper legal process,” Simone said. “But they confirmed that your mother requested the report be preserved.”
My daughter stepped closer to me. “Mom, whatever it says, I’m still me.”
I pulled her into my arms. “You will always be my daughter.”
Then Simone found a note folded into the ledger’s spine. It had one sentence in my mother’s handwriting:
If Emily learns the truth, tell her to ask James what happened at Lakeshore at 2:17 a.m.
At that exact moment, a black SUV stopped outside the storage facility.
May you like
James got out, followed by Vanessa.
And neither of them looked surprised to see us.