Chapter 2 - THE THIRD FINGERPRINT
Natalie waited until the elevator doors closed behind the man she had called her husband for five years.
Only then did she breathe.
The apartment went silent.
Not peaceful silence. Not the familiar morning quiet of expensive glass windows, humming appliances, and Manhattan traffic thirty floors below.
This silence felt occupied.
She stood barefoot in the bedroom, staring at the screen of her phone.
UNKNOWN FINGERPRINT — 47 ENTRIES.
Forty-seven times.
The third fingerprint had entered their apartment forty-seven times in eight months, mostly between midnight and four in the morning.
On eleven of those nights, Natalie distinctly remembered Ethan being home.
She checked again.
November 14. 2:06 a.m.
Ethan had been sleeping beside her because she remembered waking from a nightmare and pressing her cold feet against his legs.
December 3. 1:41 a.m.
They had come home together from his company Christmas party.
January 19. 3:12 a.m.
That was the night Ethan claimed he had food poisoning. She had stayed awake half the night bringing him water.
Yet someone else had unlocked their apartment.
Natalie opened the smart-lock settings.
The fingerprint had been registered by the administrator account.
Ethan's account.
Her stomach tightened.
She called Detective Morgan.
He answered on the second ring.
“Mrs. Parker?”
“Someone else has access to my apartment.”
Silence.
Then his voice sharpened.
“Explain.”
Natalie told him everything.
The unnamed fingerprint.
The forty-seven entries.
The sleeping medication.
The pajamas.
The strange left-handed movement.
Morgan stopped her there.
“What left-handed movement?”
“Ethan pressed the elevator button with his left hand.”
“That could mean nothing.”
“I know.”
“But you noticed it for a reason.”
Natalie closed her eyes.
“My husband is extremely right-handed. He even makes fun of himself for it. He once tried eating sushi with his left hand after hurting his wrist and dropped everything.”
“Has the man in your apartment done anything else differently?”
Natalie thought.
Tiny things suddenly rose from memory.
Ethan used to sleep facing the window.
Recently, sometimes, he faced the door.
Ethan hated cinnamon.
Three weeks ago, he had eaten French toast covered in cinnamon without complaining.
Her husband always kissed her forehead before leaving for work.
Some mornings, he kissed her cheek instead.
Things so insignificant she had never connected them.
Until now.
“My God.”
“Natalie?”
She whispered, “There have been differences.”
Detective Morgan's tone changed.
“Do not confront him.”
“What am I supposed to do?”
“Act normal.”
“You want me to act normal around a man who might not be my husband?”
“I want you alive long enough for us to figure out who he is.”
That silenced her.
Morgan continued.
“We're running DNA from the body. We're also pulling older medical files on Ethan Parker. Until we know more, don't tell him about the fingerprint.”
Natalie looked toward the apartment door.
“What if he comes back?”
“Call me.”
The line disconnected.
Natalie should have left immediately.
Instead, she did something Morgan had specifically told her not to do.
She started searching.
Ethan kept almost everything digital, but there was an old walnut cabinet in his office he never used.
Natalie opened the bottom drawer.
Tax documents.
Insurance forms.
Old photographs.
College transcripts.
Nothing unusual.
Then she noticed the drawer did not extend as deeply as the cabinet itself.
Her father had been a carpenter. He had taught her that empty space inside furniture usually meant one of two things.
Bad construction.
Or a hidden compartment.
Natalie removed the drawer.
Behind it was a narrow black envelope taped against the rear panel.
Her pulse hammered.
Inside were three things.
A photograph.
A brass key.
And a newspaper clipping.
Natalie looked at the photograph first.
Two teenage boys stood beside a lake.
Identical boys.
Same dark hair.
Same jaw.
Same eyes.
Natalie stopped breathing.
One was clearly Ethan.
The other could have been his reflection.
On the back, someone had written:
Ethan & Elias — Summer 2008.
Natalie's knees weakened.
Ethan had always told her he was an only child.
She unfolded the newspaper clipping.
The headline was twenty years old.
LOCAL BOY PRESUMED DEAD AFTER HUDSON BOATING ACCIDENT
The article described seventeen-year-old Elias Parker, who had disappeared after a small motorboat overturned during a storm near a family property north of New York City.
His body had never been recovered.
Natalie read the final paragraph three times.
Elias had been survived by his parents—
and his identical twin brother, Ethan.
A sound behind her made Natalie spin.
The apartment door.
Someone was entering.
Her blood turned cold.
She shoved the photograph and article back into the envelope, replaced the drawer, and slipped the brass key into the pocket of her robe.
Footsteps crossed the living room.
“Natalie?”
Ethan.
She forced herself to leave the office.
He stood near the kitchen island wearing the same charcoal suit he had left in twenty minutes earlier.
“You forgot something?” she asked.
“My laptop.”
His eyes rested on her.
Too long.
Natalie smiled.
“You scared me.”
“Sorry.”
He walked toward the office.
Natalie moved aside.
He stopped beside her.
For one terrible second, neither spoke.
Then he reached out and touched her hair.
“You look pale.”
“I didn't sleep.”
“Neither did I.”
He kissed her forehead.
Exactly the way Ethan always had.
Natalie almost cried.
Then he entered the office.
She listened.
Drawer opening.
Another drawer.
Silence.
Her heart hammered.
Finally, Ethan emerged carrying his laptop.
“Found it.”
“Good.”
He walked toward the door.
Then stopped.
Without turning around, he asked, “You haven't been going through my things, have you?”
Natalie's throat tightened.
She laughed lightly.
“Why would I?”
Now he looked at her.
His expression was gentle.
Almost amused.
“No reason.”
He left.
Natalie locked the door.
Her hands shook so violently that she nearly dropped the brass key.
Thirty seconds later, her phone rang.
Detective Morgan.
“We got something.”
Natalie pressed the phone to her ear.
“What?”
“The medical records.”
She stared through the windows at the waking Manhattan skyline.
Morgan continued.
“Ethan Parker did have an appendectomy at twenty-seven.”
“I know.”
“So did Elias Parker.”
Natalie's breath caught.
“The twin?”
“Yes.”
“But Elias died twenty years ago.”
“No.”
Morgan's voice became quiet.
“Elias disappeared twenty years ago.”
Natalie looked toward the bedroom where, only hours earlier, she had awakened beside the man she loved.
Morgan spoke again.
“And Natalie?”
“Yes?”
“We found DNA on the dead man's clothing.”
Her fingers closed around the hidden brass key.
“It confirms he's closely related to Ethan.”
“How closely?”
Morgan paused.
“Identical-twin closely.”
Natalie's entire world tilted.
There were only two possibilities now.
Either the man who died on FDR Drive was Ethan...
May you like
or the man who had kissed her forehead ten minutes ago was Elias.
And somewhere inside her apartment was a key to whatever her husband had spent twenty years trying to hide.
